Breaking barriers: Jewish scholar Joseph Weiler awarded prestigious Ratzinger Prize

Scholar Joseph Weiler was awarded the Ratzinger Prize for his contributions to understanding religion and society, including the case on displaying crucifixes in public schools.

Jewish Scholar awarded Ratzinger Prize

On December 1, 2022, Jewish Scholar Joseph Weiler was awarded the prestigious Ratzinger Prize at the Vatican. This award recognises individuals whose work has made a significant impact in the field of religion. This is an honour that is comparable to the Nobel Prize and it is a testament to Weiler’s contributions to the field of religion and society.^[1]

Weiler is a renowned scholar and professor of law, who has written extensively on topics such as European integration, globalisation, democracy, law, and religion. He is the author of several books and articles, and his work has been widely cited by other scholars in the field. He is also a regular speaker at conferences and events, where he shares his expertise and insights on the topic of religion and society.^{[2] [3]}

Is displaying crucifixes in schools allowed?

One of the most notable cases that Weiler had been involved in was the 2011 Lautsi case. The case was initiated by Soile Lautsi, a Finnish mother who lived in Italy, who complained about the display of crucifixes in classrooms of the Italian public school attended by her children. She argued that this violated the right to education and freedom of religion as guaranteed by the European Convention on Human Rights. The case was heard by the European Court of Human Rights and ultimately reached the Grand Chamber, which issued a ruling in 2011.^[4]

The case had a significant impact on the way that the intersection of religion and government is viewed in Europe. Weiler represented Italy and eight other countries pro bono and argued that the crucifix is not only a religious symbol but also a cultural one that represents Italy’s history and identity. He emphasised that the display of the crucifix was not imposing any religious beliefs on students, but rather provided them with an understanding of the country’s cultural heritage. The case ended with a landmark ruling that upheld Italy’s right to display crucifixes in public school classrooms and helped to establish guidelines for similar cases in the future.^[5]

The Lauci case and Weiler’s decision highlight a broader trend of societies trying to navigate the relationship between religion and government. It is a reminder that with the increasing diversity of cultures and religions in modern societies, it is crucial to find a balance that allows for the expression of religious and cultural identity without imposing it on others. The ruling in the Lauci case, which upheld Italy’s right to display crucifixes in public school classrooms, set an important precedent for how other countries deal with similar issues. In addition, it reinforced the idea that cultural heritage should be respected and understood.

The beauty of plurality

Professor Weiler is the first person of the Jewish faith to be awarded the Ratzinger Prize, which until now had been awarded to scholars belonging to various Christian denominations. This fact shows the universality of his contributions to understanding the relationship between religion and government. Moreover, it underlines the importance of finding a balance that allows for the expression of religious and cultural identity without imposing it on others.

Ghila Amati

To all news items ->

Learn more about religion and society on the EARS Dashboard

Sources

^[1] Professor Joseph Weiler received the Ratzinger Prize from Pope Francis at the Vatican – Centre for International Law.

^[2] J.H.H. Weiler – Overview | NYU School of Law

^[3] Joseph H. H. Weiler – Wikipedia

^[4] Lautsi v Italy | INTERIGHTS

^[5] Lautsi and Others v. Itlay